Metanet Forums

Pawz : http://nmaps.net/146480
lord_day : http://nmaps.net/146518
Skyline : http://nmaps.net/147015
Losttortuga : http://nmaps.net/146548
jackass77 : http://nmaps.net/146466
BNW : http://nmaps.net/146615
incluye : http://nmaps.net/146647
gloomp : http://nmaps.net/146781
NicNac14 : http://nmaps.net/146465
notsteve : http://nmaps.net/146520
bufar : http://nmaps.net/146506
179 : http://nmaps.net/146544
toasters : http://nmaps.net/146659
Riobe : http://nmaps.net/146646
ultCult : http://nmaps.net/146498

lord_day
---
gameplay : 24
replayability : 16
aesthetics : 8
total : 48
(great map. there were a couple things about it that I didn't like... took me a while to get past the upper middle section, but once I got past that the map was considerably simple and easy.)

Skyline
---
gameplay : 18
replayability : 8
aesthetics : 9
total : 35
(it was alright. I realize your object set was sparse... but you didn't seem to use all of the objects when you crafted the tiles around them. The thwump on the left, for example, is just there and doesn't do anything for the map. Overall it was just mediocre for me.)

Losttortuga
---
gameplay : 25
replayability : 18
aesthetics : 6
total : 49
(I really like what you did here. The map offered a challenge even with such minimal objects. Though the aesthetics of the whole thing seemed odd at times, the overall effect was great and I just wanted to play it over and over again.)

jackass77
---
gameplay : 28
replayability : 14
aesthetics : 9
total : 51
(whew! what a rush! I loved the map mostly for its nonlinear aspects and the amount of adventure you added with the top portion. Jumping across the top area to get the switches, then shooting down through the right side to get the final gold at the bottom... it was very well done, but replayability wasn't so great. Needed something else to keep me coming back for more.)

BNW
---
gameplay : 10
replayability : 5
aesthetics : 2
total : 17
(Really not liking this map. I realize you only had gold and a bunch of lasers to work with. Lasers are a hard enemy to use effectively, but at least some crazy, tight-knit gameplay where you're shooting down a shaft as the laser beam is just about to turn bright red... Should have used up the whole week instead of submitting with the best thing you could come up with in 24 hours.)

incluye
---
gameplay : 16
replayability : 10
aesthetics : 8
total : 34
(The gameplay picked up after getting past the gauss turrets. But overall it was a bit choppy, a bit short and not at all challenging. I completed the map with an AGD on my second try. Needed more challenge and more BANANAS, with a hint of lime.)

gloomp
---
gameplay : 14
replayability : 5
aesthetics : 6
total : 25
(little challenge and no reason for me to feel like I should play it again.)

NicNac14
---
gameplay : 17
replayability : 10
aesthetics : 7
total : 34
(Overall I thought the map was fairly mediocre. There were gameplay aspects I absolutely hated and gameplay aspects I really liked, but overall the map was awkward and didn't play very well.)

notsteve
---
gameplay : 28
replayability : 18
aesthetics : 8
total : 54
(this map was amazing. i loved how you used the objects with the tileset so well. there was a lot of adventure and a lot of challenge in this. congrats, dude, you've won this judge over.)

bufar
---
gameplay : 12
replayability : 6
aesthetics : 4
total : 22
(this map was not good at all. Personally, with the seemingly impossible gold near the lower left and the awkward gold-gathering aspect the map seemed like it would have been better suited as a closed, tight-knit map instead of an open-ended, loosely-connected map.)

179
---
gameplay : 22
replayability : 10
aesthetics : 7
total : 39
(Great map overall. Split up into categories it doesn't seem to score extremely well though. I liked the adventure aspect, which a lot of people have seemed to achieve this Week, which I find odd, since I don't normally find much adventure in most of the maps I play. Nonetheless, I liked it.)

toasters
---
gameplay : 16
replayability : 17
aesthetics : 6
total : 39
(I want to finish it. That's why replayability is so high. It's just that it's really pretty hard to do so. Nothing seems connected here.)

Riobe
---
gameplay : 12
replayability : 8
aesthetics : 7
total : 27
(Really not good. Sorry you got the one with all the drones and shit.)

ultCult
---
gameplay : 25
replayability : 16
aesthetics : 9
total : 50
(at first this map was awkward to figure out, but all the little nuances brought this map together. things like the secret path through the middle area, getting killed by the left drone in the tunnel in the top left... yeah. i liked it)

+ 30pts = gameplay
+ 20pts = replay value (replayability)
+ 10pts = aesthetics

"Petrified Laboratory" by origami_alligator
Gameplay = 12/30
Replay Value = 13/20
Aesthetics = 5/10
Total = 30/60

"Bleak Riot" by lord_day
Gameplay = 24/30
Replay Value = 17/20
Aesthetics = 4/10
Total = 45/60

"Structural Spiral" by Losttortuga
Gameplay = 15/30
Replay Value = 10/20
Aesthetics = 6/10
Total = 31/60

"Curromungle" by jackass77
Gameplay = 14/30
Replay Value = 13/20
Aesthetics = 2/10
Total = 29/60

"Nondescript Landscape" by BlckNWhteNnja
Gameplay = 18/30
Replay Value = 17/20
Aesthetics = 3/10
Total = 38/60

"Shirley" by incluye
Gameplay = 15/30
Replay Value = 10/20
Aesthetics = 4/10
Total = 29/60

"Oval Peril" by gloomp
Gameplay = 20/30
Replay Value = 11/20
Aesthetics = 6/10
Total = 37/60

"albercurthy..." by NICNAC14
Gameplay = 16/30
Replay Value = 14/20
Aesthetics = 6/10
Total = 36/60

"The Birds" by notkitt
Gameplay = 12/30
Replay Value = 11/20
Aesthetics = 4/10
Total = 27/60

"Lava Lamp" by bufar
Gameplay = 14/30
Replay Value = 13/20
Aesthetics = 2/10
Total = 29/60

"Flurry Up" by Onesevennine
Gameplay = 16/30
Replay Value = 12/20
Aesthetics = 5/10
Total = 33/60

"first timer" by toasters
Gameplay = 11/30
Replay Value = 7/20
Aesthetics = 2/10
Total = 20/60

"I Hate Objects" by Riobe
Gameplay = 15/30
Replay Value = 10/20
Aesthetics = 4/10
Total = 29/60

"a dance to half death" by UltCult
Gameplay = 18/30
Replay Value = 15/20
Aesthetics = 5/10
Total = 38/60

Petrified Laboratory by Pawz
Gameplay = 19/30
Replay Value = 17/20
Aesthetics = 9/10
45/60

Bleak Riot by lord_day
Gameplay = 25/30
Replay Value = 16/20
Aesthetics = 9/10
50/60

Marking Time by Skyline
Gameplay = 20/30
Replay value = 15/20
Aesthetics = 7/10
42/60

Structural Spiral by Losttortuga
Gameplay = 22/30
Replay Value = 16/20
Aesthetics = 9/10
47/60

Curromungle by jackass77
Gameplay = 17/30
Replay Value = 12/20
Aesthetics = 6/10
35/60

Nondescript Landscape by BlckNWhteNnja
Gameplay = 12/30
Replay Value = 5/20
Aesthetics = 2/10
19/60

Oval Peril by gloomp
Gameplay = 12/30
Replay Value = 8/20
Aesthetics = 5/10
25/60

albercurthy... by NicNac14
Gameplay = 18/30
Replay Value = 14/20
Aesthetics = 6/10
38/60

The Birds by notsteve
Gameplay = 23/30
Replay Value = 14/20
Aesthetics = 7/10
44/60

Lava Lamp by bufar
Gameplay = 20/30
Replay Value = 15/20
Aesthetics = 4/10
39/60

Flurry Up by OneSevenNine
Gameplay = 24/30
Replay Value = 17/20
Aesthetics = 8/10
49/60

first timer by toasters
Gameplay = 16/30
Replay Value = 12/20
Aesthetics = 2/10
30/60

I Hate Objects by Riobe
Gameplay = 19/30
Replay Value = 14/20
Aesthetics = 7/10
30/60

a dance to half death by ultCult
Gameplay = 23/30
Replay Value = 13/20
Aesthetics = 8/10
44/60

Marking Time by Skyline
Gameplay = 19/30
Replay Value = 12/20
Aesthetics = 6/10
37/60

Shirely by incluye
Gameplay = 19/30
Replay Value = 13/20
Aesthetics = 3/10
35/60

Petrified Laboratory by origami_alligator
Gameplay = 13/30
Replay Value = 14/20
Aesthetics = 9/10
36/60

Pawz : Did not submit
lord_day : http://nmaps.net/147756
Skyline : http://nmaps.net/147767
Losttortuga : http://nmaps.net/147820
jackass77 : http://nmaps.net/147949
NicNac : http://nmaps.net/147656
notsteve : http://nmaps.net/147666
179 : http://nmaps.net/147682
ultCult : http://nmaps.net/147625

lord_day
---
gameplay : 10
replayability : 4
aesthetics : 8
total : 22
(Way too simple. There wasn't much challenge to me. I almost completed it on the first try and almost AGD'd it on my second try, after making a stupid mistake just before getting to the exit.)

Skyline
---
gameplay : 27
replayability : 18
aesthetics : 9
total : 54
(I liked this a lot. The look of the map, the feel of the map, getting to know the routes of the map... Everything was flowy from one point to the next as each section held its own distinct challenge. Wonderful wonderful job.)

Losttortuga
---
gameplay : 17
replayability : 10
aesthetics : 6
total : 33
(The climb up to the exit was super fun. I wish it had more up/down aspects, as that seems like the map to do an up/down style with. The route was really well made, just not all the objects seemed to agree with it entirely, if that makes sense.)

jackass77
---
gameplay : 12
replayability : 5
aesthetics : 5
total : 22
(There was far too much waiting. I didn't notice many differences from the original map and this map, which I realize wasn't on purpose as you didn't see the original map before submitting... I just didn't like having to wait around for the drones to do their thing.)

NICNAC14
---
gameplay : 13
replayability : 13
aesthetics : 6
total : 32
(I liked the left half of the map, except there seemed to be a lot of waiting. The right side was fairly lacking, especially because the rocket below didn't do much for me. The gauss turret didn't do as much as I would have liked either.)

notsteve
---
gameplay : 22
replayability : 17
aesthetics : 7
total : 46
(I liked this quite a bit actually. The gameplay was well done. I really enjoyed jumping from the bottom to the top as the gauss turrets threaten you, yet you can hide from them so easily. There was something about this map that really grabbed at me. I just wanted to keep playing it.)

179
---
gameplay : 28
replayability : 20
aesthetics : 10
total : 58
(<3)

ultCult
---
gameplay : 13
replayability : 15
aesthetics : 6
total : 34
(I just started to speedrun and highscore it after a while. I wasn't sure what else to do.)

"Turn Around!" by jackass77
Gameplay = 10/30
Replay Value = 5/20
Aesthetics = 2/10
Total = 17/60

"See in Rainbows" by Losttortuga
Gameplay = 13/30
Replay Value = 10/20
Aesthetics = 4/10
Total = 27/60

"Chapmen" by lord_day
Gameplay = 23/30
Replay Value = 15/20
Aesthetics = 6/10
Total = 44/60

"dismorphic" by ultCult
Gameplay = 19/30
Replay Value = 14/20
Aesthetics = 1/10
Total = 39/60

"Understanding the Scatterbrain" by Onesevennine
Gameplay = 16/30
Replay Value = 13/20
Aesthetics = 5/10
Total = 34/60

"providence buster" by notkitt
Gameplay = 25/30
Replay Value = 14/20
Aesthetics = 7/10
Total = 46/60

"Codfish.." by NICNAC14
Gameplay = 12/30
Replay Value = 13/20
Aesthetics = 3/10
Total = 28/60

Corbin's Corner by Skyline
Gameplay = 24/30
Replay Value = 18/20
Aesthetics = 6/10
Total = 48/60

providence buster by notkitt
Gameplay = 17/30
Replay Value = 13/20
Aesthetics = 5/10
Total = 35/60

Understanding the Scatterbrain by OneSevenNine
Gameplay = 18/30
Replay Value = 15/20
Aesthetics = 7/10
Total = 40/60

dismorphic by ultCult
Gameplay = 12/30
Replay Value = 8/20
Aesthetics = 4/10
Total = 24/60

Chapmen by lord_day
Gameplay = 23/30
Replay Value = 16/20
Aesthetics = 8/10
Total = 47/60

See in Rainbows by Losttortuga
Gameplay = 26/30
Replay Value = 16/20
Aesthetics = 9/10
Total = 51/60

Turn Around! by jackass77
Gameplay = 20/30
Replay Value = 10/20
Aesthetics = 6/10
Total = 36/60

Corbin's Corner by Skyline
Gameplay = 24/30
Replay Value = 16/20
Aesthetics = 8/10
48/60

lord_day : http://nmaps.net/149848
Skyline : http://nmaps.net/150433
Losttortuga : http://nmaps.net/149808
jackass77 : http://nmaps.net/149914
NicNac : http://nmaps.net/150208
notsteve : http://nmaps.net/149891
179 : http://nmaps.net/149875
ultCult : http://nmaps.net/150016

lord_day
---
gameplay : 25
replayability : 17
aesthetics : 6
total : 48
(great map, great map, great map. the multiple paths available to me were overwhelming. much fun was had playing this.)

skyline356
---
gameplay : 18
replayability : 12
aesthetics : 9
total : 39
(the map was pretty okay. nothing spectacular, though it had good gameplay aspects that gave it some perk. overall I enjoyed it.)

losttortuga
---
gameplay : 18
replayability : 10
aesthetics : 5
total : 33
(not your best map thus far. i liked it when i first played it but it didn't maintain whatever it was i liked about it at first after playing it a few times through.)

jackass77
---
gameplay : 15
replayability : 15
aesthetics : 7
total : 37
(the map played like a lame rocket dodger, with a little extra variety. nothing spectacular, but i did want to keep playing it.)

NicNac
---
gameplay : 27
replayability : 18
aesthetics : 4
total : 50
(I loved this map. The rocket-dodging aspects in this are supreme.)

notkitt
---
gameplay : 20
replayability : 14
aesthetics : 5
total : 39
(the map looked ugly and played okay. i wasn't too happy with the fact that there wasn't much wanting me to keep playing it. i'm not sure what the drones did, but they didn't add anything to the gameplay.)

179
---
gameplay : 29
replayability : 20
aesthetics : 9
total : 58
(again, <3. the paths in this were not only fun to find but were fun to figure out how to execute. this map surprised me in more ways than one and was one of my favourite maps thus far in the competition.)

ultCult
---
ultCult was disqualified for covering up objects in his map and though I would rather not say this, he has been removed from the competition because of it.

Gameplay: /30
Replay: /20
Aesthetics: /10

"We Feel. Floating." by lord_day
Gameplay: 24/30
Replay: 17/20
Aesthetics: 7/10
Total: 48/60

"Fantastical Land" by Losttortuga
Gameplay: 10/30
Replay: 5/20
Aesthetics: 6/10
Total: 21/60

"Podge" by jackass77
Gameplay: 15/30
Replay: 12/20
Aesthetics: 5/10
Total: 32/60

"Zookoooo...." by NICNAC14
Gameplay: 11/30
Replay: 4/20
Aesthetics: 1/10
Total: 16/60

"all your maps are just a bunch of lines" by notkitt
Gameplay: 17/30
Replay: 14/20
Aesthetics: 2/10
Total: 33/60

"This is why the bridge broke" by OneSevenNine
Gameplay: 14/30
Replay: 8/20
Aesthetics: 4/10
Total: 26/60

We Feel. Floating by lord_day
Gameplay: 20/30
Replay Value: 14/20
Aesthetics: 6/10
Total: 40/60

Stumble Blocks by Skyline
Gameplay: 22/30
Replay Value: 10/20
Aesthetics: 7/10
Total: 39/60

Fantastical Land by Losttortuga
Gameplay: 22/30
Replay Value: 13/20
Aesthetics: 9/10
Total: 41/60

Podge by jackass77
Gameplay: 20/30
Replay Value: 14/20
Aesthetics: 7/10
Total: 41/60

Zookoooo.... by NicNac
Gameplay: 14/30
Replay Value: 11/20
Aesthetics: 5/10
Total: 30/60

all your maps are just a bunch of lines by notkitt
Gameplay: 18/30
Replay Value: 10/20
Aesthetics: 5/10
Total: 33/60

This is why the bridge broke by OneSevenNine
Gameplay: 21/30
Replay Value: 17/20
Aesthetics: 7/10
Total: 45/60

Stumble Blocks by Skyline
Gameplay = 18/30
Replay = 10/20
Aesthetics = 5/10
33/60