If you'll look 5 posts up, you'll see I didn't resurrect this thread to throw out my old opinions, I simply said "Let's do it. 10 maps per week." (Plus a relatively straightforward caveat)mintnut wrote:Avarin, why are you so desperate for an all-time list? I can't see the appeal, it's a list which the majority of the community will never have access to. The top ten maps of al time in this basis will all be oldies from when the submission rate was much smaller. I can only see this inducing jealous and sniping of maps like The Crazy Miner. Plus, basing a list on number of votes paves the way for n-arts to form a stranglehold on the top places.
As for whatever else I said in this thread previously, I think a top-rated list would be nice. I never had the time to browse through the top 100 action maps, puzzle maps, races, etc. I would've liked to do that. But an ongoing list (like Arachnid's suggestion) is more flexible and fair, and will (or should, at least) do a good job of highlighting good maps.
