The Neditor Nation Scrimmage Thread

http://nmaps.net/user/Pheidippides · Postby **Pheidippides** » 2009.01.05 (15:50)

The Neditor Nation Scrimmage Thread

Looking to challenge a fellow Neditor to a scrimmage? Here's the place to organize it. For those unfamiliar with scrimmages, I have their rules, taken from the Neditor Nation page of the Transcend. Blog:

Scrimmages:

Any two Neditors may scrimmage at any time. A third Neditor is required to determine the winner of a scrimmage because the Judges are not in charge of evaluating scrimmages.
At the beginning of the scrimmage, each Neditor who will be mapping chooses a rule for the maps to follow. Each Neditor’s map must follow both rules.
After both maps are complete, the third Neditor uses the universal rubric to determine the winner.
It is the responsibility of one of the three Neditors to email the result of the scrimmage to TranscendBlog(AT)gmail(DOT)com so that the spreadsheet can be updated. The results will be added to whatever the current week is when the email is received. For example, if a scrimmage takes place on Sunday of one week, but the results are received on Monday of the next week, the results will be added to the later week.

There you have it, by popular demand. Hopefully this will increase the number of scrimmages that go on each week and make them a more important part of the contest. Enjoy!

http://nmaps.net/user/maxson924 · Postby **Rose** » 2009.01.05 (17:52)

We're still allowed to arrange scrimmages in other ways, i.e. by PM, right?

http://nmaps.net/user/Pheidippides · Postby **Pheidippides** » 2009.01.05 (22:12)

maxson924 wrote:We're still allowed to arrange scrimmages in other ways, i.e. by PM, right?

Sure, but if you don't know who you want to challenge, feel free to propose a scrimmage here.

Postby **大見解** » 2009.01.06 (00:11)

hmmm.. Maybe incorporate a master scrimmage list in the first post, listing who needs a person to scrimmage against?

http://nmaps.net/user/isaacx · Postby **isaacx** » 2009.01.06 (02:48)

i'll scrimage with someone with the rule

you can only use 4 of one kind of enemy (mines don't count)

got one already

Postby **Brainwasher** » 2009.01.06 (23:42)

hmmm, I wonder if judges can scrimmage. Not for points, naturally, but for deds or comments.

http://nmaps.net/user/tinkers7777 · Postby **tinkers7777** » 2009.01.06 (23:48)

I'm scrimmaging eganic already. look if you want to see. My map is called "epic", he hasnt submitted his yet. L_D is judging, cuz he kool.

http://nmaps.net/user/isaacx · Postby **isaacx** » 2009.01.07 (13:10)

anyone want to scrimmage?

don't need one

http://nmaps.net/user/z3phyr · Postby **Zephyr** » 2009.01.08 (09:30)

Anyone want to judge a scrimmage between me and ganteka?

http://nmaps.net/user/Pheidippides · Postby **Pheidippides** » 2009.01.08 (23:44)

If anyone's got any scrimmages still floating around, be sure to get any results to me before Sunday so the scrimmages can be counted towards Week 4. Thanks.

http://nmaps.net/user/epigone · Postby **epigone** » 2009.01.09 (18:56)

I'd like to scrimmage someone. PM me if you're up for it.

Postby **Pikman** » 2009.01.09 (21:23)

z3phyr wrote:Anyone want to judge a scrimmage between me and ganteka?

Sure, I have time. I've finished my judging for the week, so I can take up a scrimmage.

http://nmaps.net/user/maxson924 · Postby **Rose** » 2009.01.10 (01:25)

Does anyone have the time to judge a scrimmage between me and lil'n? Both maps are already up; PM me if you can and I'll send the links.

EDIT: Never mind, thanks MCKY :P

http://nmaps.net/user/Guitar_Hero_Matt · Postby **MattKestrel** » 2009.01.14 (17:02)

I'll host a scrimmage too.

My rule is...

...must be based around a song :)

Also, rant about scrimmages. I hate how if you lose a scrimmage you lose points at all; it really discourages me from hosting more of these. Imo, if there wasnt a penalty for losing scrimmages, then that would encourage more people to do so. A penalty would be fine were it not punishing people for choosing to scirmmage. I know the benefit is higher, but it's still dissuading imo.

http://nmaps.net/user/isaacx · Postby **isaacx** » 2009.01.15 (02:34)

GTM wrote:I'll host a scrimmage too.
My rule is...
...must be based around a song :)
Also, rant about scrimmages. I hate how if you lose a scrimmage you lose points at all; it really discourages me from hosting more of these. Imo, if there wasnt a penalty for losing scrimmages, then that would encourage more people to do so. A penalty would be fine were it not punishing people for choosing to scirmmage. I know the benefit is higher, but it's still dissuading imo.

can it be based on any song? if so, i accept

oh yeah, if you do scrimmage with me, my rule is

you can't use thwumps

Postby **Brainwasher** » 2009.01.15 (12:56)

isaacx wrote:
GTM wrote:I'll host a scrimmage too.
My rule is...
...must be based around a song :)
Also, rant about scrimmages. I hate how if you lose a scrimmage you lose points at all; it really discourages me from hosting more of these. Imo, if there wasnt a penalty for losing scrimmages, then that would encourage more people to do so. A penalty would be fine were it not punishing people for choosing to scirmmage. I know the benefit is higher, but it's still dissuading imo.
can it be based on any song? if so, i accept

oh yeah, if you do scrimmage with me, my rule is
you can't use thwumps

Ooh, can I judge this one as the third party? Songs without thwumps is a good match. Just pm me if so.

http://nmaps.net/user/kablamo_boom · Postby **Kablamo** » 2009.01.18 (06:41)

COol

i'm up for a scrimmage. who wants to face me?

http://nmaps.net/user/maxson924 · Postby **Rose** » 2009.01.18 (12:22)

Kablamo_Boom wrote:COol

i'm up for a scrimmage. who wants to face me?

I'm up for it

Postby **deltainferno** » 2009.01.18 (12:37)

(reads wall o' text)

yeah, yeah, oh cool.

wait. wtf is a scrimmage?!

http://nmaps.net/user/MyCheezKilledYours · Postby **Cheez** » 2009.01.18 (17:07)

delta: It's when you challenge another Neditor to a map-making contest.

Anyone want to scrimmage with me?

My rule is

that you must base it after a -metal- song. (thanks GTM!)

http://nmaps.net/user/maxson924 · Postby **Rose** » 2009.01.18 (17:44)

MyCheezKilledYours wrote:delta: It's when you challenge another Neditor to a map-making contest.

Anyone want to scrimmage with me?
My rule is
that you must base it after a -metal- song. (thanks GTM!)

I'll scrimmage you too :P

http://nmaps.net/user/MyCheezKilledYours · Postby **Cheez** » 2009.01.18 (19:43)

Maxson...um...what is your rule going to be?
I'll start working on the map, and then change it if you make a rule that does something like "No more than 5 thwumps" or something.

Scrimmagin' everyone here, aren'tcha?

http://nmaps.net/user/bufar · Postby **bufar** » 2009.01.19 (02:01)

Anyone wanna do the special event with me?

http://nmaps.net/user/clarify · Postby **lil'n** » 2009.01.19 (14:14)

bufar wrote:Anyone wanna do the special event with me?

I would. I need to get off of being last place in this contest. One question, though: who will make the tileset, you or me?

http://nmaps.net/user/maxson924 · Postby **Rose** » 2009.01.19 (15:06)

lil'n wrote:
bufar wrote:Anyone wanna do the special event with me?
I would. I need to get off of being last place in this contest. One question, though: who will make the tileset, you or me?

Lil'n, you both make tilesets, and use the inverse of your teammate's tileset. I think that the two scores get added together.

MCKY and I can go against you two.

Metanet Forums

The Neditor Nation Scrimmage Thread

Who is online