me and eganic
Edit: I just hope I used the right time zone XD
Moderators: EddyMataGallos, TheRealOne
I'm not going to contest (no pun intended) something that is, after all, mostly subjective. I stand by my judging, so we'll just have to agree to disagree on this one. Anyway, maxson has yet to post his judging, so these scores are in no way final.brighter wrote:The theme of Bionic and Inspired's map isn't strong or creative enough for 17/20. Some of the judging in this contest is a little thoughtless, imo.
I was just asking for a little reasoning is all. You judged the other themes quite harshly, and all they did ws add two clocks to the tilesets which isn't very imaginative at all. I'm not talking about subjectivity, I'm talking about consistency: all your previous scores and reasoning seem out of alignment with this one.cheesemonger wrote:I'm not going to contest (no pun intended) something that is, after all, mostly subjective. I stand by my judging, so we'll just have to agree to disagree on this one. Anyway, maxson has yet to post his judging, so these scores are in no way final.brighter wrote:The theme of Bionic and Inspired's map isn't strong or creative enough for 17/20. Some of the judging in this contest is a little thoughtless, imo.
The two reasons I added marks for them was because the player (virtually) returned to the beginning of the map after travelling all the way through it and the teleporters linked the player to different areas of the map where the clocks showed different times, both of which, I felt, indicated time travel. Personally, I felt that these demonstrated the theme enough to justify 17/20. Anyway, that's my reasoning behind it; I stand by it. I'll see what maxson thinks about it (he told me that he was going to try and get his judging in soon, so hopefully we won't have to wait too long).brighter wrote:I was just asking for a little reasoning is all. You judged the other themes quite harshly, and all they did ws add two clocks to the tilesets which isn't very imaginative at all. I'm not talking about subjectivity, I'm talking about consistency: all your previous scores and reasoning seem out of alignment with this one.cheesemonger wrote:I'm not going to contest (no pun intended) something that is, after all, mostly subjective. I stand by my judging, so we'll just have to agree to disagree on this one. Anyway, maxson has yet to post his judging, so these scores are in no way final.brighter wrote:The theme of Bionic and Inspired's map isn't strong or creative enough for 17/20. Some of the judging in this contest is a little thoughtless, imo.
*raises hand* yes.... I had to submit mine late, but its here.maxson924 wrote: I didn't miss anyone this time, right? :P
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 16 guests